Why the Hamptons Has No Bike Path Like This

Go to many affluent communities in North America and you notice some kind of safe cycling path. Not on the South Fork of Long Island.

You do see, outside of winter, some intrepid bicyclists—occasionally I am one. A few streets have designated bike lanes, where vehicles shouldn’t be blocking, but rarely do these extend for long stretches.* Except for the periodic weekend bike rallies where there’s official escort and safety in numbers, it’s a hazardous activity. Especially is this true on the east-west corridors, where traffic of all kinds is barreling along tight roads to avoid congestion on the main highway 27.

Why this dearth? There’s the older explanation, and the more recent (30-plus years) one.

The long historical context is that the South Fork (aka “Hamptons”) became a destination without having a core vacation hub or even wanting to be a resort. It was a collection of old fishing and farming districts separated by woodlands even as wealthy people adopted it as a seasonal or weekend retreat. Everybody’s desire was to keep the beautiful place the way it was “before.” Result:  no new infrastructure that would accommodate a larger and active population, including bike paths (and sidewalks). Way back when, kids in the area’s towns could bike ride along sleepy roads with little care–even to school!  Then, one day in the gilding of the Hamptons, nobody could anymore.

Sure, some streets near the ocean are safe enough for summer pedaling. (Ocean Road in Bridgehampton has a bike lane extending all the way to the 27 Hwy.) Even fronting the coast, however, there’ve been struggles in the modern era.  In Amagansett, garden-landscape shop owner Charlie Whitmore recalls his father and mother, both longtime local fixtures, pressing for bike lanes along the popular Further Lane-Indian Wells Road-Bluff Road coastal stretch in the 1960s and early 1970s. The East Hampton town highway department ultimately improved the pavement, and a bit of sidewalk exists, but there’s still no secure path there, or anywhere else on the East End.

This, while New York State is actually a standout in this vein. The Empire State Trail, using disused rail lines and canal sidings, is off-road for most of its 750 miles. A strikingly good asphalt section runs from Van Cortlandt Park in the Bronx past the New Croton Reservoir in Westchester County and then well into the Hudson Valley. (A stretch near Yorktown Heights is shown above.)

It’s not that riding routes don’t exist on Long Island.  Newsday has spotlighted two dozen such paths, not including the newest and nearest to the East End, the North Shore Rail Trail from Mount Sinai to Wading River in Brookhaven town. The Trust for Public Land, pursuant to a $3.8 million federal infrastructure grant last year, is fashioning plans for a mostly-protected bike route through Suffolk County to Montauk—an attempt, along with earlier funding for Nassau County, to bring Long Island up to the New York standard. The East End’s section will come last, although a “conceptual” map for the South Fork appeared at the group’s website in April.

If that effort proceeds, it will have to surmount obstacles that met previous pushes, and here we have the recent (30-year) story.

In the early 1990s, well into the rush of Manhattan money to the South Fork, an initial bid for a cycling trail came from naturalist Mike Bottini, then affiliated with what is now the Group for the East End.  Armed with potential federal highway money, Bottini laid out a route that hugged the Long Island Rail Road line for 12 miles from Southampton to Amagansett. After a slow build, it got support from both the Southampton and East Hampton town boards, and a four-mile stretch in the middle, heading east from where the SoFo nature center now sits on Bridgehampton-Sag Harbor Turnpike, went through Southampton official review in 1999. But by summer 2000, it was drawing flak from some adjoining property owners and others who thought money should go for road repair.

 Nonetheless, a Southampton Press editorial in August 2000 said “the question, it seems, is not whether the path will be constructed, but when.”

Bottini persisted, stressing the route’s appeal in connecting various civic activity spots. The thinking was that the paved trail would have utility not just for committed cyclists but for a wider population wanting to transit between such sites without venturing onto hectic Montauk Highway. He met resistance in the village of East Hampton, out of expressed safety fears. Objections also came from an environmental flank: Friends of the Long Pond Greenbelt up the northern spine of Bridgehampton didn’t want pavement or cyclists crossing its preserved territory. (As it happens, the long-abandoned LIRR line to Sag Harbor runs through the Greenbelt.)

Bottini, by then representing a cycling group, was still pitching the idea in the Press in 2009. But a window had closed. Eventually that four-mile stretch amounted to a series of on-street bike lanes, not much different from what exists in other parts of the South Fork.  The rest of the 12 miles were largely forgotten.

On-street lanes or “routes” (which have less demarcation) were the focus of an official Southampton town advisory committee report issued in 2007.  The town board, still sympathetic to cycling alternatives, accepted the findings, which notably called for expensive widening of key routes. “Crucial,” the panel wrote, were Noyac Road along the northern tier and the primary “back road” vehicle alternative to Montauk Highway (27), which features Head of Pond and Scuttlehole Roads. These two are the inescapable east-west routes—narrow and busy with trucks and cars–for any cyclist wanting to go from town hamlet to hamlet east of the Shinnecock Canal while avoiding the 27.

Accepting a report, however, is not the same as implementing one. By 2008, a global financial crisis had put a (temporary) dent in the Hamptons ardor and political winds would shift. Although minor route enhancements with signage were made, the costly property acquisitions needed for road widening were not.

The issue came to the fore in 2011 when Tom Neely, then Southampton town’s traffic-safety chief**, led a “Complete Streets” drive to address cyclist and pedestrian concerns. The Scuttlehole Road stretch was central, but a new town highway superintendent, Alex Gregor, had been elected and he was not sympathetic. At a board meeting Gregor offered a figure approaching a million dollars for the cost of the project, and the idea sank.

Another repeated target has been the Noyac area bordering on Sag Harbor and the Long Beach bayfront.  A formal cost estimate for bike lanes from Gregor’s staff in 2014 came to nearly $800,000, mostly for road widening. The plan came to naught.  But the general area has stayed in “traffic calming” focus, and a decade later the town, using new state money, now intends a major sidewalks project there.  Ostensibly it’s for children and other pedestrians, but cycling on sidewalks is legal in Southampton town (and most of East Hampton) so there is, well, room for maneuver.

Are the South Fork winds  shifting back in favor of accommodating cyclists, either recreational or commuting? It may be notable that Suffolk County is increasingly courting tourism. Southampton town will soon end up with a short offroad stretch for biking as part of a Hampton Bays hamlet route linking Good Ground Park with Red Creek Park. East Hampton is eyeing parking fees as a way to fund bicycle lanes.  For now, however, separation from vehicular traffic is one of many obstacles facing day-to-day cyclists, as a Quixotic East Hamptonite recently found.

The cost of any land acquisitions has burgeoned as homes filled many of the wood and farm lots over the decades, and each potential neighbor is a potential objector. The LIRR’s right of way is jealously guarded by the Metropolitan Transportation Authority, even if safe sharing was possible. (Low-cost hacks such as “Toronto barriers” do make it possible to separate bikes from ordinary road traffic.) The LIPA power line that cuts across miles of open moraine on the South Fork is inviting, but also has easement issues, as well as terrain that would require heavy grading in stretches—adding to cost and opposition.  And, recalling Mike Bottini’s case decades ago, LIPA’s line is a long way from activity nodes.

Thus the TPL Greenway planners will have big hurdles to clear once their effort moves east. So far, so good—the Southampton town board agreed this month to participate. But seed money is only a start; the choices get harder. And to add to the mix, bikes and other two-wheel transit has become an acute token of cultural controversy across the U.S.—even in San Francisco as well as New York City.

In the meantime, cyclists on the South Fork will have to pick their spots…and times.  Sunday mornings seem to be best, for what it’s worth. –Aug. 23, 2024

* An exception is the Flanders Road (State Hwy 24) lanes from Hampton Bays, as seen in the photo above.  But with no barriers to the 55 mph (and higher) traffic, it is not inviting to most cyclists.

**Neely retired from the post but remains active as a transportation adviser to the town (and serves on its planning board). He ran for highway superintendent in 2021 and was narrowly defeated.

Hampton Jitney’s Tale Is LIRR’s Shame

The East Hampton Star this week adds to the 50-year commemorations of seminal events on the East End of Long Island in the early 1970s, when its transition to being a weekend and warm-weather retreat for ordinary (but affluent) New Yorkers kicked in. This short article’s focus is the Hampton Jitney, the preferred connection for those Gothamites without personal transport. A longer business history could surely be written on the Jitney–a classic case of entrepreneurs discovering a need that others hadn’t identified. (In actuality, its service to Manhattan didn’t begin until 1976.) But there’s also the flip side of this success: the failure of the Long Island Rail Road to anticipate and capture this traffic. The LIRR, owned by the state of New York since the mid-1960s, has a rich history that includes connections to the South Fork (Hamptons) since the 1880s. Over the last 50-plus years, however, it has failed to offer easy, frequent and comfortable rides from convenient locations such that even a value-conscious adult passenger would choose its service over the Jitney and similar bus shuttles. Although a train ought to have speed advantages during periods of road congestion, the LIRR rarely achieves that edge. Despite a key right-of-way that it has maintained through decades of dramatic real-estate appreciation along the route, the railroad has played only a cameo role in the remarkable story of the contemporary Hamptons, leaving room for a once-lowly form of conveyance, the jitney, to assume modern appeal.

https://www.easthamptonstar.com/business-villages/202481/hampton-jitney-rides-its-second-half-century

War Has a Way of Inspiring Migration

The world migrant population continues to rise–clocked at 281 million in what is still the last (2020) U.N. measure. There’s no reason to think it hasn’t grown since. The causes are well known: escape from tyranny, fear of persecution, hunger (literal, or for a better life), and physical exposure or danger. Often the last of these is brought on by wars that other people choose–or feel honor-bound–to fight. This is what a weekend article in the Wall Street Journal shows has brought tens of thousands of Russians and Ukrainians to unlikely destinations: Brazil and Argentina. (Of course, many more have fled the home-front’s killing and military drafts by seeking more proximate refuges.) Entry and work opportunities, as well as distance from reminders of what awaits any return, help to explain their trek across ocean and hemisphere. But this odd tale speaks to what has always been a lesser-told aspect of men’s battles: their casualties have included displacement. In modern times, America’s wars haven’t reached its continental shores, so the flight has been mostly from conscription. The Vietnam War produced perhaps 40,000 “dodgers” to handy Canada alone. Significant previous wars saw less-recognized refugees, going back to the Revolution (Loyalists) and the Civil War (on both sides). Patriotic fervor as in the two world wars might keep the numbers low for awhile, and favored sorts often find ways to insulate themselves in conflict, but before long mass slaughter drives people to uproot themselves. The silver lining, which may be true in Brazil and Argentina, is that those who shrink from war can grow to enrich both themselves and the lands that receive them.

https://www.wsj.com/world/americas/russians-fleeing-war-find-haven-in-the-cafes-and-beaches-of-south-america-23e9d26e

When Anti-Mansionization Isn’t Just Meddling

The Wall Street Journal is catching up with the movement in the Hamptons and elsewhere to contain the maximum size of homes. This week’s article focuses on the aesthetic and probably sociological objections to the mansions (the biggest ones aren’t really “McMansions” because they are built to a scale that is not…er, scalable). In response, others quoted by the Journal speak to the property rights and general freedom of people to live as they wish. This of course is a valid claim in the USA, but what the story doesn’t get into are the externalities of these homes, which can make them other people’s business. On the East End of Long Island, the underground water table and the power infrastructure are such factors, but the most acute is traffic. The multitude of trade and other service workers that huge residences require, during and after construction, causes 14-hour backups on roads and residential bypass traffic that affects nearly everyone. “Philistines at the Hedgerow” is an old Hamptons tale, but the manifestations of enormous wealth in otherwise restrained settings is becoming a national conversation.

https://www.wsj.com/real-estate/luxury-homes/towns-rebelling-against-megamansions-7f35c9f7

Review of ‘When the Clock Broke’ by Ganz

John Ganz is a trending young writer on the left with a history bent, and his new book from Farrar, Straus and Giroux, “When the Clock Broke,” is largely a political recapitulation of 1992 in the U.S. His angle is that the populist resentments of today’s MAGA America were present in that late-recessionary year, in which the country, having emerged triumphant in the Cold War, turned in on itself. (For his own fuller explanation, you can pay for his Substack feed.)

That’s an interesting proposition, placing the origins of the current distemper earlier than most others do. (Some trace them all the way to Andrew Jackson in 1828, but that’s a different discussion.) Obviously the Ross Perot phenomenon of 1992 and the related crack-up of the Reagan Republican Party under George H.W. Bush is a major flag for Ganz’s argument, and he mines the period for other useful omens (Pat Buchanan, Rush Limbaugh, Howard Stern).

Unfortunately, the author has a subsidiary aim and that is to find strands of fascist white supremacy in the unfolding drama back then (and naturally, now). So he references David Duke scores of times. The brief Louisiana legislative career of the former Klan wizard was ending as 1992 began, but Ganz sees his enduring influence in many places. My own memory of Duke is that he was a fluky, flaky presence in American politics, a footnote now like so many others of his kind. I had to check whether he was still alive.

That’s not Ganz’s only rediscovery. Murray Rothbard was an economist and cult favorite of libertarians for most of his career, until he veered into Southern populist swamps through the Ron Paul network. He merits a solid six pages–including a raring speech that inspires the book’s title–and a few other mentions. Just as obscure by general circulation was the paleoconservative writer Sam Francis, whose Manichean and racialist views are recited dozens of times, into the book’s final paragraphs. A forerunner of Steve Bannon? I don’t want to minimize the influence of the small, intellectual press but I don’t think Donald Trump would have ever read Francis, even if he had read at all.

I’d like to see more discussion of the angry populism of the time that was bipartisan. One target of this ire was NAFTA, the North American Free Trade Agreement, which Ganz notes briefly. He is good enough to record the fact that most congressional Democrats, and not Republicans, opposed the treaty when finally passed in 1993. I recall that year witnessing a union rally against the trade deal–held at the Port of Los Angeles by my own newly elected representative, Jane Harman. She would go on to rank as a notable globalist, but was not above a bit of pandering to Perotism then.

One other objection, a frequent and self-interested one of mine when it comes to pop histories of the modern American right. The Wall Street Journal’s editorial pages are cited once by Ganz, an apparently early (1989) gibe at Rudy Giuliani as a mayoral candidate.* The Journal was, during the period at issue, the largest-subscription newspaper in the U.S., and its opinion pages (which employed me then) were a bible for millions of conservatives. Arguably, its sentiments might have helped shape those times, in that camp at least? It is likely Ganz’s view that the “Wall Street” Republicanism often ascribed to the Journal’s editorials has been surmounted and supplanted by the movement he is writing about. That’s a fair position. But to have the Washington Times, by contrast, referenced on 16 pages is a bit skewed in this retrospective. Even if that narrowly targeted broadsheet did at the time employ the estimable Sam Francis!

Those reservations notwithstanding, I am glad to see a gifted next-gen writer draw on evidence from the analog era. Historical cycles do stretch, and then of course we are doomed to repeat them. I wonder what fruit today’s time capsules will bear. –July 15, 2024

*The actual citation is not included in the notes, but Giuliani at the time was still fresh off his prosecutorial frog-marching of investment bankers and conviction of Michael Milken, none of which endeared him to Journal editorialists.

Taking Hamptons Traffic Seriously

Here’s a “letter to the editor” from me, published this week at the Southampton Press site. It concerns the worsening traffic situation on the South Fork of Long Island, not only the backups on the primary east-west arteries, but the onslaught of diverted traffic onto residential roads (including–no surprise–mine). I make reference to some renderings that a full-time local resident with an architectural background, Jay Fitzpatrick, presented last month to a Southampton Town official committee set up to address the problem. I have met a few times with Jay and Barbara Fair, an involved citizen of the North Sea hamlet. Above is one of his preliminary works, showing what could be a bypass highway atop the existing Long Island Rail Road line. Such a bypass is a decades-old idea on the South Fork, which stirred earlier controversy and died. My letter argues that this outcome was unfortunate. Further background, including my own change of heart on this subject, is to be found in this 2022 post of mine. The idea remains a longshot today, but should be viewed as representative of what a meaningful response to the traffic mess could entail. (I should note that Jay makes the additional point that a bypass route would be of critical importance in the emergency of a mass evacuation to the west.) –July 12, 2024

Arf! Arf! Is a Hamptons Sound

Among the many 50-year milestones being observed in “the Hamptons” over the last year or two–reflective of the fundamental changes that were taking place there in the early 1970s–is a four-legged one. This golden anniversary year for the Animal Rescue Fund of the Hamptons (ARF), now a celebrated (and sometimes celebrity) charity, will culminate in its annual Bow Wow Meow Ball in August. This item from one of the free publications on Long Island’s East End gets into a bit of the history, but the fundamental context is that, by 1974, the area’s shift from an agricultural-fishing community with a smattering of summer beach wealth, to a year-around retreat for New York’s professional class, was in motion. The sentimentalizing of pet animals that (mercifully, in many eyes) accompanies a switch from outdoor farm to indoor house companions is a classic reflection of such transitions. ARF is not the only adoption shelter in the pet-happy area, but it’s become a big dog: in 2022 it had gross receipts of almost $5 million as it readied its latest expansion, a large indoor training hall at its headquarters in woods near East Hampton Airport. Range Rovers frequent the parking lot, even if more modest local volunteers and staff keep the place going. When the summer gala is past, the place gets more down to earth, but for the furry set of the East End, there will be no going back to the barn.

Dining Out on Taxpayers in NYC

Restaurant sheds have been a lingering point of Covid controversy in New York City, and this item in the free tabloid papers from Schneps Media ought to be reason for further debate. The sheds were allowed on public streets to save the eateries during the indoor restrictions of the pandemic. Many of them remain in place despite commerce returning to normal even in NYC, this despite complaints from neighbors about vermin, displacement of other uses and frequent unsightliness. Last summer the city council finally rang last call on the sheds, but gave the owners an additional year and the chance to maintain their public spaces with city-approved seasonal designs, which must be applied for soon. That was a big concession, compared with pre-Covid, but apparently not enough for some. Queens Congresswoman Grace Meng says she has secured $2 million in federal funds to subsidize participation of 60 restaurants in her district. So, for these 60 (and others to follow, elsewhere in town?), there will now be public space and public money for their private business. Of course, the food-and-drinks trade is rarely an easy one, and New York politicians with their laws are normally making it more difficult still, but in this case the happy hour is enjoyed by management. Street dining will continue, even if not everyone in town approves, and taxpayers in Des Moines may have their reservations, too.

Home Prices Tend to Level Out, If Not Off

Wait long enough, and many difference in residential real-estate prices get arbitraged away. That’s one takeaway, at least down to the metropolitan area, from this week’s data release from the Federal Housing Finance Agency (FHFA). It shows several instances of catch-up by areas of the country that have been less favored in recent decades. Maybe people still do move about America to seize on the “dream” of home ownership?

(A quick caveat: These FHFA numbers do not drill further down into zip codes or even towns. At that level, disparities in valuations can persist or even enlarge over longer stretches. The rich neighborhoods tend to stay that way.)

The FHFA release catches prices through the first quarter of 2024, comparing them back a few months, a year, five years, and since 1991. The last basis takes us back to the later days of the savings & loan crisis, so we can helpfully see the whole housing boom of the last 30-plus years. Longer time periods also help to correct for blips, such as the extreme days of the Covid lockdowns, although greater leeway for remote work is still doubtless a factor in recent trends.

So where do we see top price appreciations over the latest year? Would you believe, Allentown, Pa.? It’s number one, at 16%–and has a respectable 5-year gain of nearly 74%, vs. a U.S. average of 59%. You would not be wrong in thinking that the Allentown area has been a long laggard: up 228% since 1991, while American homes as a whole rose by 316%, or better than four-fold, in nominal prices.

Other metro areas that are making up for lost time include Rochester, N.Y., Camden, Buffalo and El Paso. Slowdowns, on the other hand, are evident over one- and five-year spans in San Francisco, Austin and Colorado Springs. So the larger snow to sun belt shifts occurring nationally (or as others would put it, blue to red) do not consistently hold.

Not everything evens out, even in 33 years. Wide price-appreciation gaps have persisted among losers: Honolulu (once a great winner), New Orleans and Fresno, for examples. Winners can continue to roll: Charleston, S.C., Miami and Fort Lauderdale, and San Diego. But broadly speaking, nowhere grows to the sky or sinks to pits of despond. The great multi-decade housing boom has lifted Salt Lake City by better than 675% and Hartford, Ct, by not quite 150%. Nobody went broke on equity alone, even if others really cashed in.

The FHFA also breaks down the nation by states, which is less precise but can yield political talking points. For the record, top recent and even 5-year gainers have been clumped in the Northeast (Vermont is hot!), with pandemic exceptions including Florida, South Carolina and the Mountain West. I must say, this surprised me. Also, it should be noted that the District of Columbia appears to be faring poorly in the big-government Biden presidency–it was the only “state” to decline in the latest year, and its homes appreciated less than 19% in the last five. But it had a good run through the Clinton, Bush 43 and Obama terms.

Many nonpolitical considerations account for these movements, but regression to a mean may be the most important. You have to live somewhere, and you likely wish to have “more” where you can. Perhaps my former Forbes colleague Rich Karlgaard had it right back in the early Aughts, when he published his book Life 2.0: How People Across America Are Transforming Their Lives by Finding the Where of Their Happiness.

Of course, it still helps to be able to pilot your own plane, as Rich did. Driving to Allentown, after all, is not that pleasant with all the trucks. –5/29/24

Bedroom Reform for Today’s Housing Crisis

Long Island, N.Y.’s East End has a housing price/supply crunch, like the United Kingdom. So it might want to look at an earnest argument out of the UK for addressing the scarcity by restricting or reallocating bedroom supply. (See this derivative blog post.) The scholars there found no actual shortfall of home square-footage in the British isles, but rather a hoarding of unnecessary bedroom space by a blessed slice of the population. Any Hamptonite (U.S. version) would quickly see how this applies locally, as McMansions with six or more bedrooms (nearly always with en-suite baths) are standard fare in new construction, and for only weekend or seasonal use in many situations. Back in the UK, the policy wonks looking for “fair decarbonization of housing” measures acknowledge that some potential steps for redressing the bedroom imbalance carry obviously awkward implications. So they promote instead a tax on insufficiently justified sleeping space. (There’s a bit of Henry George in that, and luxury-penalty taxes are a favored Hamptons recourse.). However, this doesn’t fully capture the social dimensions of the UK problem, which is no longer Downton Abbey estates but empty nesters of more modest means who hang onto oversized residences for lack of preferred alternatives. Thus, it’s a “tenure” issue, and one aggravated by the cumbersome ritual of unfettered private-property ownership–it skews space toward older people with deeds. If housing stock were better influenced by the state, bedroom space could be shuffled more easily among households as demographic needs change. The authors point to some Euro experiments. This more rational approach to domiciling appeals to certain academic minds, if not to the denizens of Long Island’s East End. One other reality check: The UK decarbonizers should make sure their own country’s “council” homes don’t share the static bias of New York City Housing Authority “projects.” Bigger apartments there, like those on fashionable stretches of Park Avenue, tend to stay with occupants who’ve aged beyond child-raising. Maybe, like the buyers of oversized Hamptons homes, they just wish to think the grandkids will come to visit. –5/28/24

*H/T to Rent Free, the Reason magazine newsletter by Christian Britschgi, for flagging this UK item.

https://medium.com/iipp-blog/meeting-housing-needs-within-planetary-boundaries-requires-opening-the-black-box-of-housing-9990be55cc1e